Bias Hunter
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Resources
  • Contact

Stairs vs. Elevators: Applying Behavioral Science

12/5/2015

0 Comments

 
So, last week I had the fantastic opportunity of participating in the #behavioralhack event, organized by Demos Helsinki and Granlund. The point of the seminar was applying behavioral science, energy expertise and programming skills to reduce energy consumption in old office building. We formed five different groups consisting of behavioral scholars, energy experts and coders. Our group focused on the old conundrum of how to get people to use the stairs more, and elevators less.

The first observation from us was that – apart from just shutting down the elevators altogether – there is unlikely to be a one-size-fits-all magic bullet to solve this. On the other hand, we know from research that people are very susceptible to the environment. Running mostly with System 1, we tend to do what fits together with the environment. And, unfortunately, our environments support elevators much more than stairs.
Picture
Thinking about our own workplaces, we quickly discovered all sorts of features of the environment that support elevator use, but not stairs:

  1. The restaurant menu is in the elevator
  2. There’s a mirror (apparently many women use this to check their hair when arriving)
  3. The carpets for cleaning your feet direct you to the elevator
  4. The staircase might smell, or be badly lit
  5. You can get stuck in the staircase if you forget your keycard

All these features make the elevator easier or more comfortable than the stairs. Considering that the elevator has a comfort factor advantage from the start, small wonder people refrain from using the stairs!

All in all, our solution proposal was quite simply a collection of such small items. Since the point of the seminar was to look for cheap solutions, we just proposed a sign, pointing to the elevator and stairs, with “encouraging” imagery to associate stairs with better fitness. Fixing the above list so that the stairs also include a mirror and a menu also cost almost nothing. In fact, the advantage can even be reversed: remove the mirror etc. from the elevator, and replace them with just a poster saying that walking one flight of stairs a year equals a few pounds of fat loss (it does).

For a heavier solution version, we noted that you could make the stairs vs. elevators a company wide competition, by for example tracking people in the hallways with wifi, Bluetooth etc. Additionally, stairways could have screens showing the recent news, comics, funny pictures, or anything that fits with the company culture. On the other hand, we said that probably most of the change can already be achieved with the above cheap suggestions, and so ended up presenting that as the main point.

From a meta point of view, I really had a lot of fun! It was great to apply behavioral science to a common problem – and I was surprised with the amount and quality of ideas we had. Combining people from different fields and backgrounds turned out to be a really good thing. I know it’s a kind of platitude, but I really now appreciate the fact that novices can create big insights by asking even really basic questions, since they come without any of the theory-ladenness of academic expertise :) I have to say that a fun and competent team made for a great evening!
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    December 2016
    November 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014

    Categories

    All
    Alternatives
    Availability
    Basics
    Books
    Cognitive Reflection Test
    Conferences
    Criteria
    Culture
    Data Presentation
    Decision Analysis
    Decision Architecture
    Defaults
    Emotions
    Framing
    Hindsight Bias
    Improving Decisions
    Intelligence
    Marketing
    Mindware
    Modeling
    Norms
    Nudge
    Organizations
    Outside View
    Phd
    Planning Fallacy
    Post Hoc Fallacy
    Prediction
    Preferences
    Public Policy
    Rationality
    Regression To The Mean
    Sarcasm
    Software
    Status Quo Bias
    TED Talks
    Uncertainty
    Value Of Information
    Wellbeing
    Willpower

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.